Dino,
How high was your overhead mic on the drums?
bob
Around 6ft from the floor if I remember correctly. Perhaps a tad less.
Btw, regarding the OH placement: I know it is not usual to place the mic like I did, usually it comes from behind the drummer and/or is placed quite high but did not have the space or the hardware for this so I had to improvise on the spot [not to mention the untreated ceiling]. I'm sure people don't use this approach for a reason, he he.
Dino, I saw your diagram again, and I think that the overhead being a bi-directional pattern is bringing out the middle of the drums (reducing level on the edges of the kit). This is why I didn't like the HF boost on the overhead. I think an omni, where you put it would have sounded better. Right now you have the equivalent of a mic pointing away from the drums mixed with a mic pointing at the drums. It gives too much room sound and is rejecting the cymbals. When I adjust the HF boost so the cymbals sound good, the snare looses body.
Anyway, that's what I hear.
bob
Thanks for the really detailed and insightful response oldbob! A low shelf combined with a more moderate high shelf does work but I guess you have a point there, I too hear the snare lose body on heavy EQ lift [nothing a bit of careful compression can't rectify though]. What is your adjustment for making the cymbals sound good? On your sample I do think the cymbals are too present for my liking but I get your point.
All in all I like the character of the drum sound and I think I can get something really interesting out of it.